Broken Link Building That Still Works: Find, Replace and Earn Links
# Broken Link Building That Still Works: Find, Replace and Earn Links
Broken link building is a simple idea that is easy to describe and hard to do well. You find a link on another website that no longer leads anywhere useful, you offer a page that genuinely fills the gap left behind, and you ask the editor to replace the dead link with a working one. When the replacement helps the reader, the editor has a clear reason to act. When it does not, the request is only another pitch in a crowded inbox. That difference decides whether broken link building works for a particular site, topic and list of prospects.
This guide covers the whole process in practical terms: what broken link building is, how to find broken links at scale and by hand, how to judge whether a broken link is worth pursuing, how to create replacement content, how to write outreach that helps the editor first, how to follow up without spamming, how to measure results honestly, and where the ethical and policy boundaries sit. It also explains how the tactic combines with resource page outreach, guest posting and digital PR. Readers who want done for you support can start with LinkTrixx link building services, where this work sits inside a wider programme built around competitor gap analysis and relevance first.
What broken link building is and why editors accept it
Ahrefs defines the tactic in plain terms: it involves finding a dead page and asking the sites that link to it to swap their links to a working page on your site, on the grounds that they do not want to send visitors to a dead resource. That definition puts the reader and the linking site first. The editor is not being asked to do a favour for a stranger. The editor is being offered a fix for a page that already has a fault, plus a replacement that restores the value the original link was meant to provide.
Editors accept replacements when three conditions are met at the same time. First, the broken link is real and easy to verify, with the exact page and the exact link identified. Second, the replacement covers the same reader need as the original page, at a similar or better standard, and it is current. Third, the request is short, specific and easy to act on, with no pressure and no exaggerated claim. If any condition is missing, the editor has to do extra work, take a risk on quality, or guess at the fit. Most busy editors will choose the easier option, which is to leave the page alone.
Why broken link building still works, and where it struggles
Broken link building still works when it is used for the right opportunities, and it struggles when it is treated as a volume game. Ahrefs is candid about the split in opinion among practitioners, noting that some find the tactic almost pointless while others find it works well, and concluding that execution and understanding decide the outcome more than the tactic itself. Editors still fix dead links, so the opening remains real. But editors have also seen the same pitch many times, and the easiest opportunities have often been found and used already.
Respona makes the scalability limit explicit: broken link building still works, but it is not the most scalable link building strategy, because it depends on other sites having faults, on owners caring enough to fix them, and on replacement content being a good enough fit. Opportunities are inconsistent by nature. A topic with many old resource pages, many moved or deleted guides, and many active editors will produce more opportunities than a topic with few pages and few maintainers. Search Engine Journal adds that most experienced editors see requests like this all the time, so a generic template will be recognised as a template and its success rate will fall. Judge the tactic by the quality of opportunities in your own niche, not by a claim made for link building in general.
How broken links happen
Broken links happen for ordinary reasons. Pages are deleted when a product is withdrawn, a campaign ends, or a site is redesigned. URLs change during migrations, and a redirect is forgotten, mistyped or later removed. A site closes, a domain lapses, or a tool is discontinued, and every link pointing to it fails at once. A link is typed incorrectly, or a file is moved without updating the pages that reference it. Screaming Frog explains that a 404 Page Not Found response is the most common form of broken link, and that it can occur because of an incorrect link or a page that no longer exists. The same page notes other client errors, including 400, 403, 410 and 429 responses. Before pitching, open the destination in a browser and check again on another day if the result is unclear, because a page that is only briefly down for maintenance is not a genuine opportunity. A recently updated guide with one dead link is often a better prospect than a long abandoned list with twenty, because the owner is present and a fix is more likely to be made.
Finding broken links at scale
At scale work starts with dead pages that already have links, rather than with single dead links on single pages. A dead page with many linking sites gives one replacement asset many potential prospects. A single dead link gives one prospect for the same amount of checking. Ahrefs is direct on this point: it is impossible to find highly linked broken pages without SEO tools, because even a manually found dead page needs a backlink check to show how many links it has. Scale work therefore needs a backlink database, while hand work, covered below, can find single link fixes without one.
Start with competitor broken pages
Competitors move, delete and reorganise content over time, and when they forget to redirect old URLs, their backlinks point to broken pages. Ahrefs describes entering a competing domain in Site Explorer, opening the Best by links report, filtering for 404 not found pages, and sorting by referring domains from highest to lowest. In the worked example in that guide, one competitor site had 134 dead pages, some with backlinks from over 50 referring domains. Sift the list for topics that make sense to cover, and skip a topic outside your expertise even if the dead page has many links. Semrush describes the equivalent workflow: enter a competitor domain, open the Indexed Pages report, check the box for Broken Pages, and review the list sorted by the number of domains linking to each broken page, then visit each URL and view the backlinks in context. Keep a single master list across competitors, remove duplicates, and record the dead URL, the topic, the number of referring domains, and a first judgement on fit. For a wider view of how competitor gaps should shape a programme, see our competitor backlink gap analysis guide.
Search for broken pages about a topic
Competitor lists are limited by definition, so a topic search widens the net to dead pages on any site that covered the topic. Ahrefs describes using Content Explorer for this purpose: enter a broad topic, switch the search mode to In title, filter for broken pages only, and filter for pages with at least 20 referring domains. In the example in that guide, the search returned 188 broken pages with at least 20 backlinks about content marketing. That number is an example from the guide, not a promise for every topic. Narrower topics will return fewer pages, and some will return none worth pursuing. Filter by referring domains first, then open the dead page, then check who links to it and why. If the reason for the original links cannot be recreated honestly, drop the opportunity before any content is written.
Find broken links on competing websites
A third method looks at outbound links on competing websites. Most sites link out frequently, and some of those links break over time. Ahrefs describes opening Site Explorer for a competing domain and going to the Broken Links report, which lists the dead pages that competitor links to. In the example in that guide, one site was linking to 32 dead pages. Exporting the report and sorting the broken URLs by total referring domains shows which dead pages have the widest set of linking sites. This method is useful because the competitor editorial team already judged those destinations worth linking to, and the surrounding context shows what each link was meant to do. Still read each linking page in full. A dead link inside a paragraph about a specific method needs a page that answers that specific point, while a dead link in a list needs a resource that fits the list.
Finding broken links by hand
Resource pages and lists
Resource pages curate links to useful material on a topic, and they are a natural hunting ground. Ahrefs gives two reasons: people rarely update resource pages, so they often link to dead resources, and the resources they list often have links from many other sites. Find them with search operators that combine a topic with words resource pages use, such as a topic plus intitle resources, a topic plus intitle links, a topic plus inurl resources, a topic plus helpful resources in quotation marks, and a topic plus useful links in quotation marks. Search Engine Journal shows the same patterns, with examples such as a topic plus intitle links and a topic plus intitle resources. Vary the topic wording and try neighbouring topics that the same readers use.
Reading sites by hand
Read the sites you want links from, rather than only running reports on them. Open a relevant guide, follow its outbound links, and note any that fail. Check list articles, statistics roundups, tools pages and further reading sections, and check older posts on blogs you already read. A broken link found during ordinary research is often a better prospect than one found in a bulk export, because you already understand the context and the audience. Record the linking page, the dead URL, the anchor text, the surrounding sentence, and a first note on what replacement would fit. That note becomes the core of the later pitch.
Tools and methods, with honest limits
- Ahrefs Site Explorer, Best by links, Broken Links and Content Explorer: strong for finding dead pages with backlinks, sorting by referring domains, and checking link quality and link reasons. Limit: most useful work needs paid access, and data is only as current as the crawl behind it. Always open the page before pitching.
- Semrush Backlink Analytics, Indexed Pages and Backlink Audit: strong for finding competitor broken pages, viewing backlinks in context, and auditing your own profile for lost and broken links. Limit: a high backlink count does not prove relevance or editorial quality. Read the linking pages.
- Screaming Frog SEO Spider: strong for crawling a site or page set, filtering response codes, and exporting inlinks for each error. Limit: it checks the pages it is pointed at, and it cannot judge relevance or editorial quality.
- Wayback Machine: strong for seeing what a dead page used to contain, so the replacement can serve the same reader need. Limit: not every page has a capture, captures may be incomplete, and an archived page is a research aid, not content to copy.
Respona adds a blunt limit that applies to every tool in the list: broken link building cannot be carried out effectively without investing in dead link checker tools, and free plugins alone are nowhere near as extensive as a backlink database. Hand prospecting plus one backlink tool is a workable combination. Hand prospecting alone can find single link fixes, but it cannot reliably find dead pages with many linking sites. Treat third party scores as a first filter only. A score is an estimate built from that provider link index, not a ranking signal. Judge the page by reading it: relevance, maintenance, audience, context and anchor text.
How to judge whether a broken link is worth replacing
Check link quality first
Start with a quick spot check using the filters Ahrefs suggests as a starting point: dofollow links only, exclude subdomains, a domain rating of 5 or more, and domain traffic of 20 or more. Those thresholds are deliberately low. Their purpose is to remove the most obvious low value links, such as directory, forum and comment links. In the worked example in that guide, applying those filters reduced a list from 100 backlinks to 29. The remaining list still needed manual review. After filtering, read a sample of the linking pages. Ask whether each site is relevant, maintained, and read by the right audience, and whether the link sits inside useful content. A dead page with 20 links from relevant, maintained sites is usually worth more than a dead page with 200 links from unrelated or abandoned sites.
Check why people linked
Link reasons are the more important check. Ahrefs divides links into general links, where a site recommends a resource as a whole without showing why, and deep links, where the surrounding text shows the specific reason for the link. Deep links show which points, definitions, methods, examples or data attracted links. Search the backlink report for footprints in anchor text and surrounding text, and note how many sites link for the same reason. Those repeated reasons become the outline of the replacement page. Sometimes the reason cannot be recreated honestly, for example when most backlinks reference original stats and research, a unique dataset, a benchmark, or a first hand test the team has not done. Ahrefs gives that exact warning for a study page, and the right response is to drop the opportunity before building anything.
Using archived pages responsibly
Do not copy the archived page, do not lightly rewrite it, and do not lift its examples, data, images or wording and present them as new work. Google Search Central guidance asks whether content that draws on other sources avoids simply copying or rewriting those sources and instead provides substantial additional value and originality. A replacement built by copying fails that test, and it also fails the reader test, because archived content is often out of date. If a deep link referenced an out of date statistic, include a more recent statistic from a source you have opened and can cite, or explain why the point no longer holds. Ahrefs makes the same point: make sure everything included is accurate, and if a deep link references an out of date statistic, include a more recent one.
Creating replacement content that fills the gap
Build the replacement around the reasons people linked, not around the dead page wording. Ahrefs recommends a rough outline that fulfils the same purpose and talks about similar things, then baking in the linkable points found during vetting so outreach angles make sense. Add one clear improvement that gives general linkers a reason to choose the new page: simplify a confusing explanation, visualise a concept, add a template or checklist, or rectify an error or an out of date fact. State the method, sources and limits plainly, date the page or note the last review, and link onwards to related guides so a reader who arrives through the replacement can continue sensibly. For anchor text and internal linking standards, see our anchor text strategy guide.
Outreach that helps the editor first
Write each pitch for the specific page and the specific editor, in original wording. Search Engine Journal warns that a generic template sent at scale will be recognised as a template, and that editors who have seen the tactic before know the sender is in it for a link rather than for their site success. The pitch should open with the exact broken link and the exact page where it sits, name the replacement, and give one short reason the replacement serves the same readers. Keep it short. BuzzStream found, in an analysis of millions of first emails, that emails under 300 words had the highest open and reply rates, and that shorter emails more than doubled reply rates compared with longer emails in that dataset. That finding was for journalist pitches, but the principle transfers: an editor should be able to judge the fix in under a minute.
Personalisation must be contextual, not decorative. BuzzStream analysed more than 12,000 campaigns and found a baseline reply rate of 16 percent for template only emails with merge fields, a fall of 1.3 percent for fake personalisation, and a rise of 10.7 percent for contextual personalisation that tied the ask to the contact work. Fake personalisation, such as a generic compliment about a post the sender has not read, performed worse than no personalisation at all. Ahrefs recommends a hybrid approach: segment prospects by link reason, and write a personalised template for each segment, with deep linkers receiving a version tied to their specific reason and general linkers receiving a version built around the improvement in the replacement. Find the right individual, not a generic inbox, and never demand a specific anchor text or a link in return for pointing out the fault. For wider outreach standards, see our link building strategies for 2026 guide and our guide to vetting guest post sites.
Follow up without spamming
One thoughtful follow up is usually enough, and it should add value rather than repeat the first email. BuzzStream analysed more than 65,000 campaigns and more than 8 million emails and found that sequences with follow ups saw an 85 percent higher reply rate than one and done emails, that the first follow up was the most impactful, and that reply rates fell by 66 percent from the first follow up to the second email in the sequence. The same study found the best reply rates for follow ups sent within a day, while noting survey evidence that only 8 percent of journalists thought it was acceptable to follow up more than once. Treat those findings as directional, not as a rule for every editor. A site owner who maintains a resource page on a slow cycle may need longer than a journalist on a daily deadline.
Measuring results honestly
Measure placements, not only replies. A reply is not a link, a promise is not a placement, and a placement on a page nobody reads is not the same as a placement that sends relevant readers. Keep one record per prospect with the linking page, the dead URL, the replacement offered, the date of each contact, the reply, the live URL if placed, and a check that the link still works after a few weeks. Semrush recommends regular audits to track new, lost and potentially harmful backlinks, and that habit belongs in broken link building too. Check for lost replacements, check that linked pages still describe the site accurately, and check that anchor text stays natural and varied. Our guide to measuring link building ROI and our guide to how many backlinks are needed to rank apply the same honest standard: judge progress by relevance, referral quality and sustained visibility, not by a link count alone.
Report ranges and context, never a guaranteed rate. Search Engine Journal primer reports, from the author own experience, a success range of 5 to 50 percent and a minimum average of one link per month across industries, while stressing that results vary by industry, effort and the quality of sites targeted. That wide range is the point. Set your own baseline over a first batch of 30 to 50 well vetted prospects, review which segments replied and which placed, and then decide whether to continue, change the replacement, or change the prospect list. BuzzStream also found that reply rates alone can mislead, because different outreach types produced similar reply rates but very different placement rates. Count live, relevant placements, and review the reasons behind non replies before scaling any part of the process.
Ethics and spam policy boundaries
Broken link building is editorial outreach, and it stays on the right side of policy only when the link is earned by usefulness and the editor chooses freely. Google Search Central spam policies define link spam as creating links primarily to manipulate rankings, and list buying or selling links for ranking purposes, excessive link exchanges, automated link creation, and low value content created primarily to manipulate linking and ranking signals. The same page states that buying and selling links is a normal part of the web economy for advertising and sponsorship, and is not a violation as long as such links are qualified with a nofollow or sponsored attribute. The boundary is therefore clear: do not pay for a replacement link that passes ranking credit, do not require a link as a condition of pointing out a fault, do not use automated programs to create links, and do not build scaled, unoriginal replacement pages whose main purpose is to collect links.
Common mistakes
- Pitching before checking the link, the linking page and the backlinks behind the dead page.
- Building a replacement for a dead page whose links come mainly from low quality, irrelevant or abandoned sites.
- Copying or lightly rewriting the archived page instead of writing original, current content.
- Offering a product or pricing page where the reader needs a guide, a definition, a method or a dataset.
- Sending the same generic template to every prospect, with only a name and a URL changed.
- Demanding a specific anchor text, a followed link, or immediate action in the first email.
- Following up repeatedly, contacting several people at one site, or treating silence as a reason to escalate.
- Counting replies as links, reporting a success rate from one small batch, or promising a fixed number of links per month.
- Paying for a replacement link without qualifying it, or hiding a commercial relationship from the editor and the reader.
- Chasing volume across unrelated topics instead of building a small set of strong replacements in one niche.
How broken link building combines with other tactics
Semrush divides tactics into link producers, which are accessible and can generate volume, and association producers, which take more effort but build stronger brand association. Broken link building and resource page outreach sit in the first group, while digital PR, guest blogging and becoming a source sit in the second. A balanced programme uses the first group for steady, relevant placements and the second group for authority and visibility. The prospect list, vetting notes and contact record built for broken link building serve every other tactic, provided the team does not return to the same editor too often or with too many asks at once. A resource page editor who accepts a replacement may later consider a new guide, a guest contribution, or an expert comment. Our digital PR guide explains the second group in full, our guest posting service follows the same editorial standard for contributed articles, and our link insertions work requires the same context check: the link must make sense where it sits. For agencies, white label link building lets the same standards run under the agency brand. Teams that need to set timing expectations should read our guide to how long link building takes.
A practical four week starting plan
In week one, build the list and vet it. Choose one niche, list 5 competitors and 10 resource pages, run the at scale checks, and score every candidate on relevance, link quality, link reason, recreatability and owner activity. Keep only the candidates that pass most checks, and record the rest as rejected with a reason. In week two, build one or two replacements, not ten. Write original content, check every fact, add the improvement that gives general linkers a reason, and review the draft as an editor would. In week three, send short, segmented pitches in small batches, with one follow up only for prospects who have not replied after a reasonable interval. In week four, verify placements, log live links, check for broken or changed links, review which segments worked, and decide the next niche or replacement based on evidence. For SaaS teams, the same plan applies with product led guides and documentation as replacement assets, as explained in our SaaS link building guide.
Final thoughts
Broken link building still works when it is treated as editorial help rather than as a numbers game. Find dead pages that matter, check why they mattered, build a replacement that earns its place, and ask once, clearly and politely, with the fix made easy. Measure live placements, respect editors who say no or say nothing, and keep the tactic inside policy by earning links through usefulness. Done that way, a broken link is not only a fault to exploit. It is a chance to restore value to a page, to a reader and to a site, and to start a relationship that outlasts a single link.
Frequently asked questions
What is broken link building?
Broken link building is the practice of finding a link on another website that leads to a dead page, creating or offering a page that fills the same reader need, and asking the editor to replace the dead link with the working page. Ahrefs describes it as finding a dead page and asking linkers to swap their links to a working page, because they do not want to send visitors to a dead resource.
Does broken link building still work?
Yes, for well vetted opportunities, and no, as a volume tactic for every dead link. Ahrefs notes that opinion is divided and that execution decides the outcome, while Respona notes that the tactic is not the most scalable strategy because it depends on other sites having faults and owners caring enough to fix them. Judge it by live placements on relevant, maintained pages in your own niche.
How do I find broken links worth replacing?
Start with dead pages that already have backlinks, using competitor broken page reports and topic searches, then vet the backlinks for quality and link reason before building anything. Semrush describes finding competitor broken pages through the Indexed Pages report, and Ahrefs describes sorting by referring domains and checking whether the dead page has desirable links. Resource pages, checked by hand, are a useful second source.
What should a broken link building email say?
It should name the exact broken link and page, name the replacement, and give one short reason the replacement serves the same readers, in original wording written for that editor. BuzzStream found that emails under 300 words had the highest open and reply rates in its analysis, and BuzzStream found that contextual personalisation improved reply rates while fake personalisation reduced them. Keep the email short, specific and free of pressure.
How many times should I follow up?
Usually once, with a refreshed angle or added value, and then stop unless the editor shows interest. BuzzStream found that follow up sequences saw an 85 percent higher reply rate, that the first follow up was most impactful, and that reply rates fell sharply after it. Repeated follow ups risk blocking and relationship damage, so a single polite follow up that makes the fix easier is the safer standard.
Is broken link building against search policy?
No, when the link is earned editorially by usefulness and the editor chooses freely, and when no payment or requirement is involved. Google Search Central spam policies treat buying or selling links for ranking purposes, excessive exchanges and automated link creation as link spam, and state that paid links are acceptable only when qualified with a nofollow or sponsored attribute. Do not pay for a replacement link that passes ranking credit, and disclose any commercial relationship honestly.
Sources
- Ahrefs Broken Link Building: The Complete Guide
- Semrush Link Building for SEO: What Works in 2026
- Search Engine Journal Broken Link Building: What You Need to Know to Get Links
- Search Engine Journal 6 Things to Know About Broken Link Building
- Google Search Central Spam Policies for Google Web Search
- Google Search Central Creating Helpful, Reliable, People First Content
- BuzzStream BuzzStream Data: The Outperforming Outreach Tactics We Learned From Analyzing 12,000 Campaigns
- BuzzStream Follow Up Emails in Digital PR: What the Data Tells Us
- BuzzStream Does Email Length Matter? What 5M Emails Tells Us About Engagement
- Screaming Frog Issues: Response Codes, Internal Client Error 4XX
- Respona Broken Link Building in 2026: Is It Scalable?
- Wayback Machine Search the History of Web Pages